Pumpkin Rising

[EWildcat7]

Although the weather is warming up and it is not really time for a winter brew, the holiday season has made me think of pumpkin beer.  I was looking through the Coopers and Mr. Beer recipes and found that they each have a beer called Pumpkin Rising.  They have similarities and differences.  So, I wanted to ask those on here who are more experienced than I am for their option as to which one you all think would be better based on the respective ingredients.  Here are the recipes:

https://www.diybeer.com/au/recipe/pumpkin-rising.html

https://www.mrbeer.com/pumpkin-rising-recipe

Thanks in advance!